What Is Brooklyn Style Pizza? Choose the Perfect Slice

brooklyn style

Brooklyn is the cultural hub of New York City. It has many things it is known for, and its pizza is without a doubt one of them. Brooklyn Pizza just hits differently. Just mentioning it creates images of a thin, crisp crust, perfectly bubbled cheese, and zesty tomato sauce.

But what makes Brooklyn Pizza so different from all these other styles of pizza out there? And how is one supposed to capture that perfect bite? In this article, I will answer these questions and tell you a little bit about the history of Brooklyn-style pizza, what makes its crust characteristically unique, and how you should take that perfect bite of quintessentially Brooklyn-style pizza.

Origin of the Brooklyn-Style Pizza

The history of Brooklyn-style pizza dates back to the formation of the Italian-American community in Brooklyn in the 1900s. The style was developed when the traditional ways of making pizza in Italy and the innovativeness of American cuisine came together. Brooklyn’s diverse population contributed to the evolution of pizza into a local culinary art form.

Simplicity is the basic constituent of Brooklyn-style pizza. A few top-quality ingredients, expertly combined, give that taste and texture that causes one’s mouth to water. The classical trio of dough, sauce, and cheese unfolds, and each element contributes to the general perfection of a slice.

brooklyn style pizza

Image source: Pinterest

Brooklyn-Style Pizza: What Is the Sauce and Cheese About?

Other than the crust, other heavily contributing entities to the taste configuration of the Brooklyn-style pizza are the toppings. The base tomato sauce is rich and full of taste, produced from high-grade, ripe tomatoes. The simplicity of the sauce lets the innate sweetness of the tomatoes come forward and complements the other elements without crowding them out.

The topping of Brooklyn-style pizza, in most cases, involves Parmesan and mozzarella. The cheese melts perfectly into that oozy, gooey goodness to glue all those delicious toppings right to the crust. The topping on the sauce and cheese is just right, delivering the balance that Brooklyn-style pizza stands for. So, every bite becomes a full, flavorful journey.

Brooklyn-Style Crust: Thin, Crispy, and Irresistible

The most distinctive feature of Brooklyn-style pizza is the crust. Pizzas from other regions, as you might know, come with a thicker crust. A Brooklyn-style pizza’s crust is thin. The result is a delightful crunch with every bite. The secret? It lies in the dough—a mixture of flour, water, yeast, salt, and olive oil that creates an airy and crispy dish.

Who doesn’t love a good crust-to-topping ratio? The Brooklyn-style pizza delivers. A good stretch ensures a thin crust and a uniform distribution of toppings. The result of this step is lightness and pliability, so the pizza folds easily. It is a standard Brooklyn pizza-eating method. The foldable Brooklyn crust isn’t just a nifty means of eating on the go—it’s a signifier of the Brooklyn pizza experience.

brooklyn style pizza what is

Image source: Pinterest

Choosing the Perfect Slice

Scaled the Brooklyn Bridge before? Me, neither. It sounds daunting enough, and finding the right slice of pizza might cause you to sweat as much as your adventure on the bridge. But fear not. A few pointers can guide you to the perfect Brooklyn pizza.

  • Local Favorites: Begin with the local favorites. The neighborhoods in Brooklyn are lined with pizzerias, some hallowed by time itself. Ask locals for their recommendations and be prepared to find those hidden gems—places that may not even be known to tourists.
  • Crust Preferences: Consider your crust preferences. If you have a thing for thin and crispy crusts, then look for pizzerias that are pros at Brooklyn-style pizza. Many establishments proudly display their dedication to the Brooklyn tradition, making it easier for you to find your ideal slice.
  • Toppings and Combinations: Look out for the toppings and combinations offered. While classic cheese and pepperoni are timeless choices, some of the Brooklyn pizzerias have really brilliant, original topping combinations on offer. Do not be scared to leave your comfort zone and try something new to understand the creativity that Brooklyn-style pizza entails.
  • Ambiance and Tradition: Soak up the atmosphere and tradition of the pizzeria. Most of Brooklyn’s pizzerias are historical, and their feeling is one of community. Choosing a pizzeria that embraces these elements can enhance your overall pizza experience.

Local Influences on Brooklyn-Style Pizza

Before one can capture the real deal of Brooklyn-style pizza, one has to appreciate the first local influences that have shaped its evolution. The essence of Brooklyn neighborhoods is cultural diversity, which seems to be so in the pizza-making tradition. Numerous Italian-American families, each with their unique culinary heritage, have contributed distinct flavors and techniques to the Brooklyn-style pizza. You will find the different methods of pizza making as you go through the various neighborhoods. This offers a deeper connection to the local history and community.

I must say that Brooklyn-style pizza is more than just a dish—it’s an art form. Pizzerias in Brooklyn boasts the craftsmanship that goes into every pizza. Right from hand-tossing the dough to picking up the freshest ingredients, this makes a great testament to the dedication of the pizza-makers. Some even allow “behind the scenes” tours, with kitchens open for anyone wanting to see firsthand what goes into making the perfect Brooklyn-style pizza.

brooklyn crust

Image source: Pinterest

Brooklyn-Style Pizza Beyond Brooklyn

Be it in Manhattan, Queens, or anywhere not limited to New York, pizzerias have their own version of the classic Brooklyn slice. In that alone, it speaks so much as a testimony that even outside Brooklyn, there is still a universal love and regard for the very special Brooklyn-style pizza.

As the borough changes, so does the pizza scene in Brooklyn. With new generations of pizzaiolos springing up and experimenting with flavors, techniques, and ingredients, the future of Brooklyn-style pizza has a bright outlook and possibilities. The fusion of traditional methods with contemporary culinary trends is an assured way in which Brooklyn-style pizza remains a dynamic and relevant force in the world of pizza. Monitoring the emergent pizzerias, collaborations, and innovations allows you to be at the forefront of the next wave of Brooklyn-style pizza experiences, ensuring that the tradition lives on for years to come.

Key Takeaways

Brooklyn-style pizza is not merely a simple food; it is an entire cultural experience when decades of tradition are brought to their apogee. It’s a combo of slim, crispy crust, a flavorful sauce, and high-quality cheese, all in one piece, evoking the real Brooklyn spirit.

As you move through Brooklyn, into and out of its neighborhoods, take the time to savor the different interpretations of this iconic pizza style. From the classical Margherita to creative and innovative versions, there’s surely a slice for everyone’s taste in a Brooklyn pizzeria. So next time, while in the neighborhood, take the culinary trip and choose the perfect slice for your pizza-eating pangs.

Emily Kaufman, an avid writer, immerses herself in millennial culture, relishing social media trends, celebrity buzz, and all things viral. With a penchant for pop music and a guitar as her creative outlet, she embodies the quintessential millennial girl.